2005 "Most upscale / creative dining"
2004 "Best upscale dining"
2004 "Best Outdoor Dining"
2003 "Best Upscale Dining"
1997 "Best Lunch Spot"
1997 "Best Dining for Herbivores"
"The Back When Cafe exemplifies our hometown values of outstanding quality and customer service"
2003 "Best new building project"
'Governer Jim Doyle and the Wisconsin Department of Commerce hereby recognize your dedication to downtown revitalization, economic development and historic preservation.'
